I've been watching Supergirl this season with a pretty mixed impression the whole thing. As a Superhero story it's not bad and I really like Melissa Benoist's version of Supergirl but the thing that bugs me the most about the show is that no matter what they do she can't seem to get out of the shadow of her cousin, Superman. Kara Zor-el also Kara Danvers is determined to live up to her more famous relative and the show constantly fails her because the creators of the show have boxed themselves into a very narrow corner. In their wisdom Superman's shadow looms large over the show but he's never on it and it's really becoming a problem. Not to mention the fact that Kara is fighting a whole bunch of angry Kryptonians one of them was her Aunt and Superman is no where to be found. Why wouldn't he be there to help her, because the writers don't want him there because they are afraid he'll overshadow her and he might but we'll never know. Also as a fan of the comic I am very aware of the long history of Superman and again the writers have decided to just co-op his stories onto hers. Like Bizarro and the Black Mercy from one of the best Superman stories ever written by Alan Moore and drawn by Dave Gibbons called For the Man Who Has Everything. Also other than Martian Manhunter her Scooby gang is pretty lame, Toy Man's good hearted hacker son Wynn, Jimmy Olson who is played well by Mechad Brooks but he everything about him is plot service, he isn't able to be his own man here. Either the show is trying to force him to be a love interest for Kara when I don't see much chemistry between them or he's spouting wisdom at her like a fortune cookie at key moments. Otherwise poor Mechad doesn't have much to work with. Maxwell Lord is such a poor man's Lex Luthor it's becoming criminal on the show. Also Cat Grant played by Calista Flockhart just sucks, she's vapid and annoying and I hate that the show tries so hard to make her deep or something. She's gotta go which is why I think they need to do something drastic. Something unexpected, take Kara even further out of her comfort zone and maroon her in the 31st Century, with a new Scooby gang that's right comic fans, The Legion of Superheroes.
So this would breathe new life into the show and really raise the stakes. Also it solves the Superman problem. He isn't there he can't be this is the future and he's already long gone. The creators can have some fun with the new setting and slowly bringing the Legion of Superheroes together: Brainiac 5, Lightening Lad, Phantom Girl, etc etc. The list goes on, it could cost a bit more but it would be completely different and she could end up having her own original storylines and they wouldn't feel obligated to ape Superman's all of the time. Not to mention you have plenty of Legion of Superhero comics to pour through for ideas. This is what needs to happen to keep the show fresh and interesting. But in the meantime they need to ditch the rogue Kryptonians, bring on some other heroes into the mix and get her a better support team, stat!
Supergirl aires on CBS on Monday's at 8PM